Showing posts with label Walter J. Phillips. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Walter J. Phillips. Show all posts

Sunday, August 31, 2008

Class War, Part 3: And the Winner Is...

The auditorium was filled with the sound of people murmuring about Mr. Phillips' "perfect" classification system. I had always known Mr. Phillips was nuts. But I had never, until now, realized exactly how nuts he was.

"The man is insane," I said, scarcely able to speak. "The man is literally in...sane!"

"I have to admit, I really don't get this," said Ivan Large, puzzling over the photocopied handout of the Greater Perfect System. "Am I crazy, or does this make absolutely no sense?"

"No!" I said, no doubt sounding slightly delirious. "You're not crazy!"

There were a few more presenters after Mr. Phillips, but I didn't pay much attention, as my mind was reeling from the unsettling realization that I had been the apprentice to a mad librarian for the last four months.

My classification system was the last one to be presented. When Ivan and I had discussed the contest earlier, he had casually mentioned that I would be required to present my idea before the conference. Sensing my alarm at the prospect of speaking in front of a large audience, he had willingly offered to present it for me, "because," he said, "I really believe in your idea and I think it needs to be heard." However, after the revelation of the true nature of the GPS (and of Mr. Phillips' mental state), I no longer cared so much. I'm not sure why. Maybe it was because, after initially thinking of Mr. Phillips as a great genius, the realization that he was actually crazy made me feel more confidence in my own ideas. I hadn't even been completely serious when I thought up my system, and even now I wasn't sure that I meant it completely seriously, at least not for use as an actual library classification system (everything is shelved under "X"?... come on!). But I did feel that there was an important and valid idea behind it, and that beneath its absurdist and seemingly nihilistic surface, there was a deeply significant truth about human knowledge and its limitations, and that truth was what I, and Ivan, believed in.

I told Ivan I wanted to present the system myself, though I would still like for him to introduce me, an unknown non-librarian. "It would be my honor," he said.

We proceeded to the stage. I felt a little nervous but surprisingly calm. Ivan Large took the podium first. "Our final classification system was created by a good friend of mine, Curtis ----. Curtis does not have an MLS, but in my view that should not dissuade us from considering his ideas, for it is, in my opinion, the ideas themselves that we should consider, and not the official credentials of the person who has conceived those ideas. For credentials, though they may mean something in our world, are not in themselves what give thought and originality to a human mind. Curtis has much experience working in libraries and has been developing his own ideas about classification while being assigned to help develop another classification system, which for everyone's benefit shall remain unnamed. His idea may seem shocking at first--though I don't think it will appear as shocking as certain other systems that have been presented here today--but I ask you to look beyond the surface and see what it is that Curtis is really trying to express. I think that if you keep an open mind, you will agree with me that his system--let's call it more a theory or a philosophy of classification--embodies great insight into the very nature of what it is that your noble profession strives to do: namely, to attempt to comprehend and organize human knowledge. I will tell you offhand that this system--Curtis has dubbed it "System X"--is not meant to provide a practical framework for an actual library classification. It attempts to do something else, and that is to make us think about classification itself, indeed human knowledge itself, and the limits of both. Take it, if you will, as a bit of perspective. I've said enough. Now, to speak for himself, I present to you Curtis ----."

I had to admit that was the most comprehensible utterance I had ever heard from Ivan Large. I stood behind the podium and looked out at the hundreds of librarians who stared back at me, waiting. I'm sure that I didn't speak as eloquently as Ivan had, but I think I spoke well enough. I remained calm and presented my thoughts in a logical way. The exact words aren't important, and there would be little point in reproducing here ideas which I have already told you elsewhere in this blog. Suffice it to say that I presented my realization about the infinite complexity of the universe, and how classification is based on perceiving relationships among various entities, and that ultimately all classifications are incomplete. I assured them that this did not mean that there was no value to classifying things--that classifying was, in fact, a necessary and essential part of human life, both in and out of libraries. We have to have a system of understanding the world and what things are and how different things relate to each other. My point, I said, was simply that we realize that all such systems, devised as they are by human beings with incomplete knowledge, are bound to be themselves incomplete, and that this knowledge--about the limits of our knowledge--should keep us humble. I had come to the conclusion, I told them, that classification systems can serve either of two purposes (not mutually exclusive): they can be practical, or they can be works of art. (That was one point on which I had come to agree with Mr. Phillips, though his own work of art was evidently no more than the scribblings of a madman.)

"And so," I said, "I am here to present to you my work of art. As Ivan told you, it is not meant to be a practical system. It is simply an expression. At first glance, it may appear nihilistic, but I can assure you that it is not. Somewhat tragic, perhaps, but not nihilistic. But to me, more than anything else, it expresses the vastness and richness of the universe in which we live, that we can never completely know because we can never get to the bottom of it. Anyway, I won't explain it any further. Here it is."

There was a laptop at the podium for the presenters to use, and I typed something quickly before having it projected. The audience saw a blank white screen with one short line of text in the center:

EVERYTHING=X

The audience was silent. I couldn't tell what they were thinking. I didn't really have anything more to say about it, or at least I didn't want to say anything more about it (that is, I didn't want to overexplain it), so I thanked them and walked off the stage. The audience applauded, with something less than standing-ovation enthusiasm yet something more than mere politeness. It didn't matter, though, what the professionals thought, or if I won one of the top three prizes. I had presented my idea, and that was enough.

"That was absolutely brilliant!" said Ivan as I left the stage. "You really floored them!"

"Well, I don't know if I would say floored, exactly."

"Trust me, you floored them."

"If you say so."

Sometime later, they announced the winners. Third place went to something called the White-Edwards Characteristic Ontology. Second place went to the Automated Referential Metadata Schema (or ARMS). These were a couple of the ones that I hadn't paid much attention to when I was still in shock over the depth of Mr. Phillips' dementia. Was he honestly delusional enough to hope, at this moment, that he would win first prize? Yes, I nodded to myself, he probably was.

"And the winner of Class War III is..." said the presenter, opening the envelope and taking a moment to make sure he had read it right. "System X, by Curtis ----!"

I just sat there, stunned. "Go, go!" said Ivan, pushing me. I stood up, half-dazed, and walked up to the stage. The audience applauded, much more enthusiastically this time. I didn't notice, but I can be sure that Mr. Phillips was none too pleased.

So there you have it. I, the librarian's apprentice, won Class War III. Not that I had much in the way of formidable competition, least of all from my mentor and his "perfect" (perfectly demented, that is) classification system. Ivan, Monica, and I celebrated by going out for drinks that night. The next day we flew back to St. Louis. On Monday Mr. Phillips called me into his office and told me my apprenticeship was complete. I think this was his polite way of saying "you're fired" (not from my job as a shelver, but from my apprenticeship). That was fine with me. And so this blog must come to an end, since it is, after all, my blog about that apprenticeship. I have decided I'm going to go to library school and get my MLS. I've learned all I can learn from Mr. Phillips and at any rate if I want to work as a professional librarian for anyone other than him (which I most certainly do), I need the credential. But I have a feeling that the most important part of my education in librarianship will always be what I learned this summer while I was the apprentice to the great librarian Walter J. Phillips.


THE END

Friday, August 29, 2008

Class War, Part 2: Perfection Revealed

The second presenter was a long-haired woman named Julie wearing an inordinate amount of bracelets. "I'm here to speak to you today," she intoned in a high, airy voice, "of the Harmonic Synchronicity System. I prefer not to use the term 'classification' because it implies a hierarchical order that embodies privilege and prejudice. A classification system is exclusive, whereas my system is inclusive; it is bound by logic, whereas mine is guided by intuition; it is rigidly structured, whereas mine is organic and free. On my Website, anyone can contribute to the Harmonic Synchronicity System by adding intuitive tags to items and linking items together according to his or her innermost feelings. No ideas will be rejected; all ideas will be welcomed and considered of equal value and validity. Through this welcoming, truly democratic system, a great harmony will be achieved and result in an awakening to potential and possibility."

"I couldn't understand a darn thing she was saying," said Ivan Large. He swooshed his hand over his dome. "Right on over it."

The third presenter was Mr. Phillips. "I am here today," he announced importantly, "to present the Greater Perfect System of Library Classification. That's GPS-LC for short, or just GPS, if you prefer. The Greater Perfect System represents a radical evolutionary step beyond the so-called Perfect System that I presented last year, and which I now call the Lesser Perfect System. I am having a handout passed out that shows a simplified diagram of the system."

A few conference volunteers moved down the center aisle, handing each row a stack of papers (for each attendee to keep one copy and pass the rest to the next person). The paper handouts were necessary, of course, because Mr. Phillips refused to touch a computer. I don't know how much money he spent on photocopies.

I looked at my copy of the diagram. It was actually the first time I had seen the overall structure of the system to which I had supposedly been contributing for the last three months.

My jaw dropped.

Here, in simplified form, is Mr. Phillips' idea of the perfect classification system:

Class A: Things that exist.
Class B: Things that do not exist.
Class C: Things that are large.
Class D: Things that are small.
Class E: Things that are visible.
Class F: Things that are invisible.
Class G: Things that are red.
Class H: General information.
Class I: Theories of Walter J. Phillips.
Class J: Books about horses.
Class K: Things that are simple.
Class L: Things that are complex.
Class M: Things that are Chinese.
Class N: Books written by Democrats.
Class O: Books written by Republicans.
Class P: Books written by Bolsheviks.
Class Q: Books written by the Chinese.
Class R: Fairy tales.
Class S: Things that are certain.
Class T: Things that are uncertain.
Class U: Things that matter.
Class V: Things that do not matter.
Class W: Things that are known.
Class X: Things that are unknown.
Class Y: Things that make sense.
Class Z: Things that do not make sense.

"I don't get it," said Ivan Large.

No further comment is necessary.

Tuesday, August 19, 2008

A Dream Come True

Today Mr. Phillips finally gave me his response to my work on the GPS. Even though I had long since stopped caring about the project, I couldn't help feeling a bit nervous when he called me into his office to discuss it. I sat facing him across his large wooden desk and braced myself. Mr. Phillips looked at me intently.

"Brilliant!" he said.

I was stunned. "Really?"

"Absolutely brilliant! I knew you were the right man for the job!"

I had no idea how he "knew" this, since I knew nothing whatsoever about classification at the start of the project (and more or less made it up as I went along), but I knew that to point this out to Mr. Phillips would have been, well, pointless.

"I believe," he stated, sounding more tremblingly excited than I had ever known him to be, "that you and I, Curtis, will emerge victorious in Class War! We have created the Phillips-[my last name] Greater Perfect System!"

At this point I was reminded of my dream where Mr. Phillips shouted, "I have achieved perfection!" Uncanny.

Well, I must admit I do feel relieved, though I'm afraid that if the GPS does not win first prize, Mr. Phillips will be terribly crushed. It also makes me feel torn about entering my own idea into the contest, even though I would have absolutely no expectation of it actually winning. The judges would surely think it was a joke, and in truth it isn't meant to be completely serious. The only way it would stand any kind of chance is if Ivan Large were one of the judges.

Thursday, August 14, 2008

Dreams of Perfection

This morning I had a strange dream. I was in a laboratory with Mr. Phillips. We both wore white lab coats and were somehow supposed to be working on the classification system. It was as though Mr. Phillips was Dr. Frankenstein and I was Igor. There were books and sheets of paper strewn across a long table, and I was rummaging through them really fast, sorting and organizing them into stacks, and it seemed to be a race against time. Finally Mr. Phillips raised his hands toward the thundering, lightning-flashing sky and proclaimed, "I have achieved... perfection!"

After this I dreamed I was at Vivian's house. I've never been there in real life, so I have no idea what it actually looks like, but in the dream it was an old Victorian townhouse. She told me to classify everything in her house--books, dishes, clothing, you name it. It was an arduous task because Vivian made sure that I got everything perfect.

Boy, was I glad to wake up.

Tuesday, May 13, 2008

The IQ Test

Ok, so I had to "classify" a box of bones. Easy, right?

Well, considering that I know almost nothing about anatomy, not so easy. I wasn't sure what type of animal these bones were from, or even if they were all from the same type of animal. How was I supposed to find out? I suppose I could find some books on animal bones...

And how should I classify them, anyway? By size? Shape? Body part? Species? Who could say? Mr. Phillips was out of the library all day, so I could not ask him for clarification. I only had a one-word command: CLASSIFY.

Was this some kind of intelligence test? A lesson in the difficulty of classification? If it was the latter, then I can say that I learned my lesson well. When you know next to nothing about bones, classifying bones is a near impossible task.

Well, I started out the best I could, organizing them by general size and shape, what looked like leg bones here, what appeared to be vertebrae there...

But this approach soon became complicated. At some point it becomes hard to know how to group things, what to put together and what to keep apart. Which is more important, the similarity or the difference? At one extreme, you just have to lump them all together as "bones"; at the other extreme, each bone is a unique individual specimen. Is every object a prime number, divisible only by itself and one? Are there really "kinds" of things, or are all classifications arbitrary? It seems there would have to be real kinds... all of these objects are obviously bones. But what about different kinds of bones? Are the divisions between different types of bones as definite and clear as what divides bones from non-bones? And of what greater thing are bones just one kind? Is there only a single group to which they belong? Can't we say that bones are a kind of this thing, but also a kind of that thing? And wouldn't everything that exists ultimately have to be a "kind" of one ultimate thing? A kind of what? Thing? What is a thing, anyway?

While my head swirled with such vertigo-inducing philosophical questions, the bone classification exercise became increasingly difficult and frustrating. Just when I thought I had a good system down, the next bone specimen would throw a wrench in the works and I had to rethink all of my assumptions.

Where did Mr. Phillips get all these stupid bones, anyway? Why does he have them? Just to torment me?

Mr. Phillips finally stopped by right before 5 o'clock to look at my work. "Interesting," he said.

"Well?" I asked. "Did I get it right?"

He gave me a funny look. "Right? Why, young man, you miss the whole point. As I told you, classification is an art." He shrugged nonchalantly. "There's no right answer." He chuckled and turned to leave. Needless to say, I was smoldering.

I almost didn't want to believe him. I didn't want to believe that I had just wasted eight hours of my life trying to find something that didn't exist. I wasn't sure if I should be more angry with Mr. Phillips or with myself. So last night I sulked.

Today, I started to think that maybe, just maybe, Mr. Phillips was wrong.

Saturday, May 10, 2008

Dewey Decimation System

On Friday Mr. Phillips called me into his office. "Allow me to let you in on a secret," he said.

I waited. Then Mr. Phillips leaned forward, looked at me seriously, and said:

"Dewey was wrong."

I had to think for a moment. "As in the Dewey Decimal system?"

"The very one! Well, I'm here to tell you that Melvil Dewey, creator of the much-vaunted Dewey Decimal Classification system, didn't know what the hell he was talking about!"

"He didn't?"

"No! To think that you can classify everything that exists into ten and exactly ten groups? How convenient! And that each of those ten groups is further divisible into ten subgroups, and so on? Such a neat and tidy cosmology! As though the universe does everything in tens!"

"I never thought of it that way."

"Well, let me tell you this: The Dewey Decimal Classification system is something to be surpassed! Mankind can do far better!"

"What about the Library of Congress system?" I ventured, remembering my work in a university library.

"Library of Congress?! You've got to be kidding! Leave it to the United States government to devise the single worst classification system known to man! Why, it's hardly even worthy of the name! The word 'system' at least implies that there is some sense to it! The problem with Dewey is that it has too much sense; with Library of Congress, that it has--as one would expect of anything associated with Congress--too little sense!"

"So what is the answer, sir?"

"I'm so glad you asked, young man. Because that brings us to the very crux of librarianship and indeed of your apprenticeship. Classification. It is the heart of the matter. It is what we librarians do. We take the vast multitude of books that exist and we sort them out into some kind of comprehensible system. Otherwise, people would never be able to find what it is they're looking for. But it is more than that. That is just the practical, day-to-day outcome. Ease of finding is all they teach you in library school, but that is merely the natural result of classification. Classification, my boy, is an art, the finest art in the fine art of librarianship! A classification system is like architecture, like poetry, like music! Unfortunately for the world, however, Dewey's system is utterly dull and prosaic, while Congress's is pure noise! What we need is a classification system that will rise up like a symphony of human knowledge, in perfect harmony!"

I have to admit that at this point I thought Mr. Phillips was starting to sound a little crazy. Idealistic, yes, brilliant even, but just a little bit nuts. That is, until the next thing he said...

"And you, young man, are going to help me compose the perfect classification system!"

Then I thought he was totally out of his mind.

Wednesday, May 7, 2008

The Tech Guru

Today the Foundation's main IT guy, whom I shall call Jason, came into the library to make a presentation about databases and why they are a good idea for storing the Foundation's archival records and documents. (Yes, the Foundation itself does have computers, just not its library, in the sense that none of the library functions have been computerized. Some of the individual library employees have computers in their offices, but not, of course, Mr. Phillips, who refuses to have one of "the devil's tools" on his desk.) I don't need to tell you that Mr. Phillips was a hard sell on this idea of digital archiving.

"Preposterous!" he blurted out in the middle of Jason's presentation.

Jason just stood there for a moment, unsure how to respond. He is a younger guy, about my age, with bushy dark hair, beard, and glasses. Definitely a "geek" type, and the philosophical opposite of Walter J. Phillips in every way imaginable. Finally he said, "And how is it preposterous, Mr. Phillips?"

"Leave it to a tech guru to come up with the perfect way not to preserve documents!" [At this point I saw Jason give Monica a quizzical frown and mouth silently, 'guru?'] "Do you really think your computerized toys are going to last as long as these books? When it comes to archiving, I'll put up good old-fashioned paper against your bright and shiny gadgets any time!"

"Mr. Phillips," said Jason with patience and a hint of amusement, "it's true that paper does have many good qualities and it's a medium that has served us well for a long time. However, the truth of the matter is that paper decays--you have millions of books sitting on library shelves right now silently rotting away--whereas digital files are capable of being around indefinitely. So I would--"

"Indefinitely?!" Mr. Phillips interrupted. "That's what you tech gurus think, isn't it? You think that all your computer files are going to be around forever! Well, you mark my words, young man, I predict that all your digital files will vanish long before my books!"

"Really. And how do you figure?"

"Why, just think about it! Have you heard of peak oil?"

"Of course. It's when the global oil supply begins to decline. But what--"

"Well, computers, and all the digital files they contain, depend on electricity to keep them going, don't they?"

"Yeees..."

"So when the oil becomes more scarce and more expensive, so does the electricity, and the more costly it becomes to keep the computers up and running and the digital files alive! And when the oil runs out, there goes the power grid, and all your computers are worthless, your digital files gone forever!"

Jason chuckled. "But you're forgetting about alternative energy sources--"

"I'm sorry, but I can't entrust the future of important documents to blind optimism! When all the computers lie dead, the books will still be sitting on the shelves, just as readable as ever! Now, if you'll excuse me, I've heard enough of this nonsense. Quite frankly, to continue further would be a waste of my time and yours. Good day, Mr. ----."

Mr. Phillips left the conference room, leaving Jason, the IT guy, stunned. He looked at us and shook his head. "Unbelievable," he said with faint hilarity. "Simply un-believable."

Monday, May 5, 2008

Library Perverts

So today I asked Mr. Phillips why he chose me to be his apprentice even though I don't have an MLS. I should have known such a question would set him off.

"That is precisely why I chose you, young man," he said, "because you haven't had your mind warped by library school and the perverse doctrines that it teaches."

I couldn't help asking. "Perverse?"

"Yes, perverse! They call it Library Science! Science! Librarianship, my boy, is not a science! It is an art! That's right. The librarian is an artist, and the library his work of art. A library is one of the most complex and intricate works of art that man is capable of creating. It consists of a building or room, true, and shelves, but these are the mere frame for the painting, which consists of the books. The librarian chooses which books to include, and combines them into a harmonious whole, a veritable symphony of knowledge!"

Interesting notion, I had to admit. When I was growing up I had never thought of my local public library as a work of art. I had also never thought of the old lady who checked out my books to me as an artist. Then again, I had never thought of her as a scientist either.

"But what is even more perverse than the heresy of Library Science," continued Mr. Phillips, in full tirade mode, "is the blasphemy of Information Science! Information! To think," he protested, "that libraries can be reduced to information! It boggles the mind!"

I was afraid to confess that it wasn't perfectly obvious to me what the problem was with saying that libraries were about information, but Mr. Phillips saw the questioning look on my face.

"Really!" he said, indignant. "What kind of philistines run these schools today, to insist that libraries serve no higher purpose than the dissemination of facts and information?" [He said the word with palpable distaste.] "Libraries, young man, are about knowledge! Knowledge is not something you can 'Google'--if it were, we'd all be geniuses by now, wouldn't we?--no, it's something that you earn through hard work and diligent research, and above all, intensive reading and thought!"

I nodded. Walter J. Phillips is a rather intimidating man, and someone in my position does well to nod frequently and keep silence. Besides, I know next to nothing about librarianship, and Mr. Phillips is highly reputable in the field, if controversial. Later in the afternoon, while shelving periodicals (I'm still officially a shelver), I looked up the October 2003 issue of Libraries Today, which one of my coworkers had shown me when I first started. Mr. Phillips is featured on the cover of that issue, an authoritative scowl on his face. The caption reads, THE DOUGLAS ARTHUR FOUNDATION'S WALTER J. PHILLIPS: CONTRARIAN LIBRARIAN.

Boy, I thought. They sure got that right.

Saturday, May 3, 2008

Library School

I have to say that not everyone at the library is pleased about my apprenticeship. Take Monica (as I shall call her). She is one of these oh-so-cool hipster librarians who wears black frame glasses and vintage clothes and thinks she can look down her nose at me just because she has an MLS and a superior command of the Dewey Decimal system. On Friday she saw me stamping due date cards (yes, again), and remarked that it was a mere clerical task and had nothing to do with what professional librarians do, and wondered why Mr. Phillips made me practice such a menial action so obsessively. I told her I didn't know but I trusted that Mr. Phillips, being the great librarian that he is, must have had some very good reason for making me practice due date stamping. Then she shrugged and made some comment about how it was highly unexpected that Mr. Phillips chose me to be his apprentice when I hadn't even gone to library school. She didn't come right out and say it, but I know that Monica is jealous and feels that the situation is unfair. The way I see it, though, Mr. Phillips is putting me through his own unique version of library school. I don't know why he chose me, though. I'm not one to question good fortune, but it does make me a little curious. Perhaps I'll ask him about it on Monday.

Thursday, May 1, 2008

Due Dates

Today Mr. Phillips made me practice stamping due date cards, the way the librarian used to check out books to me when I was a kid. Mr. Phillips is an older gentleman, what some would call a cranky old man, and is fiercely, you might even say maniacally, conservative (not necessarily politically--I have no idea what his politics are--but certainly when it comes to librarianship). I think he has been running this place for about 30 years and he has managed to this day to prevent the intrusion of computers ("those infernal machines", as he so colorfully refers to them) into the Foundation's library. Indeed, when I first started working here last fall, I felt like I was stepping back in time, back to my childhood in the 70's when the library still had a card catalog and the librarian stamped the due date on the little due date card and stuck it in the pocket in the back of the book. Well, the electronic age has yet to arrive at the library of the Douglas Arthur Foundation, and, as long as Walter J. Phillips is in charge, the 21st century will just have to wait.

Mr. Phillips had to attend some important meeting this morning, so he delegated the actual due-date-stamping training to his second-in-command, a fiftyish woman whom I shall call Vivian. Vivian has been here almost as long as Phillips and seems his equal, if that were possible, in library conservatism, while successfully managing to embody just about every librarian stereotype you've ever heard. She wears cat-eye glasses, her brown hair is invariably pulled up in a bun, and I'm pretty sure she's unmarried. I've heard her mention her cat, but never anything about a husband or children. I once saw her shush some important members of the Foundation who were chatting in the reading room. They respectfully, if begrudgingly, complied.

Anyway, Vivian demonstrated for me the correct method of stamping due date cards. "First," she said, "you pull the card out of the pocket."

She pulled a card out of its pocket in the back of a book.

"Then you take the stamp... if it's the beginning of the day, make sure it is set to the correct due date..." [she held it up so I could see that it was set to 15 MAY 2008, two weeks from today] "...then you ink it... not too much ink, mind you. Next you stamp the card on the first empty line on the left hand side, unless that side is full, in which case you stamp it on the first empty line on the right. Now watch, this is very important... you must bring the stamp down at a 45-degree angle, like so... then roll it, gently but firmly, up then down... applying just the right amount of pressure... too little and you've left an incomplete date, too much and you've made an ungodly mess. Then you return the stamp to its holder... and lastly, return the card to the pocket, quietly close the book, and slide it discreetly to the patron. You know, of course, that libraries do not have customers, they have patrons. A library is not a business."

"Of course."

"Very good. Now here, you give it a try."

Nervously, I tried to emulate all of Vivian's moves. Every single one of her motions had displayed complete perfection and the utmost elegance, which I suppose had come with almost three decades of practice. She really has this due date stamping thing down to a science. Perhaps even an art. My first attempt was less than perfect.

"Darn," I said, careful not to swear in front of the stern Vivian.

"That's all right, it's your first time. You'll improve with practice. Here," she said, producing from a drawer a huge stack of due date cards, "why don't you go into the workroom and practice until ten o'clock."

Two hours of stamping due date cards? Well, I told myself, if this is what it takes to become a great librarian, I'm willing to put in the time. After all, great musicians don't become that way without hours of repetitive practice, right?

I've gotta tell ya, though, my hand is still sore.

Tuesday, April 29, 2008

Day One: The Meaning of the Word

Well, my first day as an apprentice librarian was interesting. I showed up at 8:00 in Mr. Phillips' office--and what a lovely office, by the way, with a huge wooden desk and leather chair, and the walls lined with wooden shelves filled to the brim with old books, plus stacks of books on the desk--and reported for my new duty. Phillips seemed distracted at first, looking around for something, and didn't seem to notice when I walked in. I cleared my throat and he said, "Oh, there you are,"--as though I were just the thing he had been looking for--"do have a seat, young man."

I sat nervously in a plush armchair facing his desk. I waited another minute or so as he continued to ruffle through papers and books. "Ah! There it is!" he said at last, triumphantly holding a small red volume that I had been eyeing absently ever since I sat down. "Have you ever read Virgil?"

Embarrassedly, I said, "Um... no, can't say that I have, sir."

"What? You studied literature in school and they never gave you Virgil?"

"Technically, I was an English major. Virgil, if I'm not mistaken, is Latin."

"And I suppose you never took Latin?"

"Uh... no. No, sir."

Phillips shook his head in disbelief. "I say, what do the universities teach anymore? No Greek, no Latin! How can they take themselves seriously as supposed institutions of higher education? Harvard! Yale! What jokes they have become!"

I sat silently, feeling as inadequate as ever I had, intimidated by the great librarian and his towering intellect. If he could scoff at Harvard and Yale, how pathetic must I have seemed, with my state-university bachelor's degree in English Lit?

"But none of this is your fault, my boy," said Phillips. "You are merely the victim of the laughable state to which our educational system has fallen. No one who goes to college in this day and age receives a real education. It's simply appalling. But let's move on." (I sighed with relief at that change of subject.) "So you really want to become a librarian?"

"Yes, sir. I trust that you can teach me how."

"Very well. Let's start with the fundamentals, shall we? Isn't that the way education usually works? You start with the fundamentals, and move on to the... the higher..." [he swirled his hand, trying to come up with the word] "...well, whatever. You know what I mean." He gazed at me seriously. "Do you know what the word library means?"

Was this a trick question? "Uh... well, at the very least, it's a place where there are lots of books."

"Exactly!" He sat up emphatically. "A place where there are lots of books! Not computers, not Web sites and blogs, not, God forbid,video games... but books! The word library, young man, comes from the Latin word liber. Do you know what that means?"

"Book?" I ventured.

"Precisely! The word book is at the very heart of the word library. My goodness, library basically just means the book room! Not the computer lab! Not the Internet cafe! Not the video game arcade! Not Blockbuster Video! The book room!"

I nodded, hardly daring to speak.

"Here, let me show you something." I followed Mr. Phillips out of his office, into the main reading room, and into the stacks. He pulled an old volume at random off the shelf and thrust it in my face. "Smell!"

"Excuse me?"

"You heard me! Smell it!"

I sniffed. The dust almost made me sneeze, but I caught it.

"Do you know what that smell is, young man?"

I wanted to say dust, but guessed that would have been the wrong answer. "What?"

"That," he said, "is the smell of knowledge." He held the book to his nostrils and inhaled deeply.

I never knew knowledge had a distinct aroma, but I took his word for it. He, after all, was the great librarian Walter J. Phillips.

"Look around you. Do you know where you are?"

Again, I surmised that the obvious answer was not the correct one.

"You are standing," he said, "in the Republic of Letters. Do you know who are the citizens of that noble republic?"

"Who?"

"All those who have written great books, the poets and philosophers, the novelists and playwrights, historians, scientists, political thinkers, you name it... all those who have taken part in the Great Conversation, those who have spoken their parts in the great drama of human civilization, and moved on to let others take the stage. And the library is where you come to take part, to kneel at the feet of the brightest and best minds of history, to learn from the greats! This is where education takes place, young man."

I nodded, overwhelmed by his passionate outburst.

"You see all these books? Each one of these books embodies a living person, a great man or woman who had something to say to the world, and said it! Most of them are gone, but their voices remain, recorded in the pages of these books, ready to speak to you if you only turn the page."

I stared around me at all the books on all the shelves. It was almost spooky, imagining that in each one was someone's voice, someone's mind, all waiting silently for me--for anyone--to listen. Standing dwarflike in that immense sea of knowledge, I came to feel viscerally the magnitude of my ignorance, and at the same time an awakening desire to acquire as much of that knowledge as I could. This was more exciting and more meaningful than acquiring economic wealth... there before me, as though a newly discovered country, was a whole world of intellectual riches that was free for the asking.

Mr. Phillips explained to me that librarians, being keepers of the books, should make it their business to know the books, and expressed his opinion that reading should take up a considerable amount of the librarian's time. In view of my poor education, he took sympathy and assigned me to read from the classics--in English translation--for the remainder of the day.

Monday, April 28, 2008

Meet the Apprentice

I shall call myself Curtis, though that is not necessarily my real name. I am 35, single, and find myself at this stage of life to be curiously ambitionless. That is all you need to know about me. The purpose of this journal is to document my apprenticeship to the great librarian Walter J. Phillips, which begins tomorrow morning at eight o'clock. Mr. Phillips works in the library of the Douglas Arthur Foundation here in Saint Louis. I have a couple of friends who are librarians, and they are always telling me I should go to library school (since I am an otherwise unemployable English major who has worked a chain of lowly library-clerk and bookstore jobs for paltry pay and even less esteem), so I know that apprenticeship is not the usual route to becoming a librarian these days. But one of these librarian friends recently informed me of an opening for a book shelver at the Foundation, and Mr. Phillips hired me during the first (and only) interview. Don't ask me why. He is a brilliant but eccentric man. This was about six months ago. I have enjoyed working at the Foundation very much. It is so quiet and civilized, quite unlike some of the public libraries I have worked in.

Well, last week, I was surprised when Mr. Phillips, a very busy and important man who had hardly spoken to me, indeed who I had barely seen, since starting the job, called me into his office and made me a very unexpected and unusual offer. He asked me if I had an interest in becoming a librarian, and I assured him that yes, I did, only I hadn't gotten around to attending library school just yet. Then he told me that library school was really quite unnecessary and asked me if I would be interested in being his apprentice. At first I didn't know what to say. The word "apprentice" only made me think of Mickey Mouse and Donald Trump. No doubt sensing my confusion, Mr. Phillips proceeded to tell me that in the past, up until librarianship became professionalized sometime in the 19th century, librarians learned by apprenticeship, and that he was all for the older ways and such, library school being, in his opinion, almost as much of a joke as business school. He said all they taught you in library school these days was computers, and that computers had nothing to do with libraries, and so forth. The gist of it was that I was offered the opportunity to be the apprentice to Walter J. Phillips, and I willingly accepted.

Tomorrow I will let you know how the first day goes.